Consumer NZ has reviewed the usefulness of mobile billing information for the second year in a row and is disappointed by the lack of progress made by New Zealand’s three Pay Monthly mobile providers. The Commerce Commission engaged Consumer to undertake this independent review.
In 2021, the Commission asked the three telcos to improve the information they provide their customers around usage and spend so they can easily compare plans. Consumer NZ’s 2022 review found progress in some areas but significant opportunities for more improvement. However, this year’s review found overall, not much has changed.
“After initial positive steps from the industry, it’s disappointing that further improvement seems to have stalled,” says Tristan Gilbertson, Telecommunications Commissioner.
Consumer NZ’s 2023 review found the 2degrees, One NZ and Spark billing apps still present information about their customers’ phone spend and usage in awkward and inconvenient ways. While some providers have good annual summaries, Consumer found that only 13% of customers said they recalled receiving them.
“The Commission now sees a case for considering whether further measures are required such as a ‘right plan’ obligation that would require providers to tell their customers when there is a better plan based on their usage and spend,” Mr Gilbertson says.
The results
• 2degrees came out on top for the second year in a row. Its customers are best equipped to assess their own needs, with an easy-to-find, clear and detailed summary of spend and usage. However, like last year, 2degrees was let down by its annual summary, which still lacks historical spend information directly in the email.
• One NZ performed better than in 2022 (when it was trading as Vodafone NZ). Its annual summary was rated higher than the other telcos – providing clear average monthly usage information, a monthly breakdown of data used and information on other plans. However, the app only reports usage over a two-to-three-month window and information about a customer’s ‘regular’ or ’extra’ plan spend is displayed across multiple menus, meaning customers have to do the maths themselves.
• Spark came second equal with One NZ. While its billing app does have easy to understand data on usage and spend, it is still hard to find. However, in the past month, Spark has launched a new initiative where customers receive plan recommendations based on a six-month period. While Consumer has not been able to consider the new initiative in its assessment this time around, it notes that Spark should consider basing plan recommendations across 12 months in order to factor in seasonal trends, which play a significant role in data use. Nevertheless, the initiative appears to be more comprehensive and consumer-friendly – a good sign Spark is trying to improve.
Why transparency is important
“When you look at how phone spend and data usage is presented on these billing apps, it’s no wonder that over two-thirds of us have stayed with our mobile phone provider for five or more years,” says Jessica Walker, campaigns manager at Consumer.
“Customers should be able to access basic information about how much data they’ve used and how much it’s cost them. This would enable people to make informed decisions about whether they’re on the best plan for their needs.
“Data, calls and texts are virtually the same across all providers, so telcos should expect their customers to be looking for the cheapest plan out there.
“Being on the wrong plan can cost you hundreds of extra dollars per year. It’s worth seeing what you can understand from your telco’s billing app and switching if there’s a cheaper option.”
Read the full review here: https://consumernz.cmail20.com/t/i-l-attwdt-tujukrhyq-y/
Notes:
The Commerce Commission engaged Consumer NZ to undertake this independent review.
About Us
Consumer NZ is an independent, non-profit organisation dedicated to championing and empowering consumers in Aotearoa. Consumer NZ has a reputation for being fair, impartial and providing comprehensive consumer information and advice.
We also do a podcast on consumer issues; Consume This available here. Consider supporting us today – join at consumer.org.nz
The Commerce Commission is New Zealand’s competition, consumer and regulatory agency. We play a crucial role in ensuring New Zealand’s markets are competitive, consumers are well informed and protected, and sectors with little or no competition are appropriately regulated.
Our vision is that New Zealanders are better off because markets work well and consumers and businesses are confident market participants.
