Source: Family First
MEDIA RELEASE – 27 May 2025
Family First is appalled to see that the Ministry of Health has once again erroneously reported euthanasia numbers in New Zealand including one quarter where the number of deaths nearly doubled.
“This raises significant concerns about the upcoming review of the law and whether it will be based on actual quantifiable and credible evidence,” says Bob McCoskrie, CEO of Family First.
Reviewing recent quarterly reports from 2024, there are so far two instances where numbers have changed substantially – in one case, nearly doubling the numbers of those euthanised. In the third quarter of 2024 (01/07/2024 to 30/09/2024) the number of deaths leapt up from 73 to 129; an increase of 77%! In the quarter prior (01/04/2024 to 30/06/2024) the number of deaths was revised down from 126 deaths to 108 deaths.
“The Ministry appears to have no idea what is going on. Whether the number of deaths each quarter are being revised up or down, the system is failing to account for what is happening and consequently it is impossible for anyone to argue the system is operating safely.”
Family First has previously raised safety concerns around how the euthanasia system is working in New Zealand, including reported numbers not aligning. There were also concerns from whistleblowers within the End of Life Choice Review committee pointing out that they were being denied access to information and that doctors’ written accounts of deaths varied from what they described in voice.
“If the Ministry can’t even count the numbers correctly, how on earth can New Zealander have any confidence that the euthanasia system is working safely. Are they getting the criteria correct that patients must meet. What else are they missing?” asks Mr McCoskrie.
That the Ministry is also updating its reports quietly and with no public notification or acknowledgement of what has changed is also a red flag.
“The Ministry’s willingness to try and sweep such changes under the carpet indicates a system that is neither safe, transparent, or accountable,” said Mr McCoskrie.
Family First is calling on government to intervene immediately in the interest of public safety. In particular, the recent review of the End of Life Choice law clearly needs to be independently reviewed and revised. Not only is this review based on wrong numbers and trends, but also written by the same Ministry who continue to publish false data.
“Dead or alive, the Ministry seems to have no idea.”
Family First is also deeply concerned by comments by Associate Minister of Health David Seymour who is overseeing the review of the law. He stated in a media interview last year: “The statutory review is being the Ministry of Health right now. I believe, without pre-empting what it will say, that it will give a lot of weight to making change.”
If the Ministry can’t report the figures accurately and reliably, how can we trust the review of the law?
