Source: Massey University
The US Government’s messaging around Covid-19 preventative measures changed under different leaders.
Democrats during a rally in the 2020 US presidential election
Republicans during a rally in the 2020 US presidental election
New research has found handwashing and mask-wearing in the United States since the 2020 election have decreased among Republicans as a sign of loyalty to outgoing President Donald Trump while these behaviors have increased among Democrats.
Head of the School of Communication, Journalism and Marketing Professor Stephen Croucher, alongside Senior Lecturers Dr Niki Murray, Dr Doug Ashwell and Shawn Condon and Lecturer in Digital Marketing Dr Phoebe Fletcher have carried out a longitudinal study that examined whether the adopted COVID-19 preventive behaviours of Democrats and Republicans changed over a long period of time after the election and whether political bias played a part.
The 2020 United States presidential election was a key focal point in the COVID-19 debate. The election took place in the midst of growing cases, debates over the efficacy of mask-wearing, other preventive behaviours (like social distancing), rampant misinformation spreading about COVID-19, growing fears over the virus, and mounting economic and political division across the nation.
Under the leadership of President Donald Trump, Americans were told mask-wearing and other preventive behaviours (including lockdowns) were not necessary, while actions such as handwashing were encouraged. After the inauguration of President Joe Biden, the Government’s messaging changed to be in favour of preventive measures and Americans were encouraged to wear masks, social distance and wash hands regularly.
“We applied several social-cognitive models of health behaviour to determine what motivated individuals to increase or decrease the use of these preventative measures,” Professor Croucher says.
“Using a longitudinal-panel study, participants were asked a range of survey questions about their demographic, how often they washed their hands after being in a public place, how often they wore a mask inpublic, and a Fear of COVID-19 scale modified from the Fear of HIV/AIDS Scale,” he adds.
Data for this study was collected in September and December 2020 in the United States from 345 participants who were self-identified Christians, Caucasians, born in the United States, and either registered Democrats or Republicans.
These particular demographics were chosen to ascertain how the dominant ethnic and social population has responded to the COVID-19 pandemic and preventive measures.
“Not only did the results show the frequency of mask-wearing and handwashing changed over time, but they also found personal fear of COVID-19 had a positive effect on the change in frequency of handwashing and mask-wearing among the entire sample,” Professor Croucher says.
The results also suggest the belief that the virus is a public health concern did not influence the frequency of handwashing and mask-wearing. “Results showed fear of exposure to the virus, or fear of contact with the virus, decreased the likelihood of adopting preventive behaviours. We attribute this result to people tending to socially distance from those they do not know.”
Professor Croucher says the increase from Democrats may be a result of several factors; United States President-elect Joe Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris both appeared speaking wearing masks when the election result was clear. He suggests they may have acted as strong role models to Democrats illustrating how easy it was to wear masks in public, thereby increasing feelings of self-efficacy among their supporters to wear masks and increase their handwashing.
Professor Croucher says the evidence supports the Social Determination Theory; a framework that suggests a person’s political affiliation might influence their decision to adopt health preventive behaviours because they desire to seek approval from others affiliated with that particular political ideology and/or alternatively they feel pressured by those with similar political affiliations.
“Democrats may have been more inclined to wear masks because of contingent rewards and social approval they would receive after the election, when the political rhetoric had changed to encourage mask-wearing and other health preventive behaviours,” he says.
“In contrast, the drop in Republicans wearing masks may be explained by their faith in then President Trump who downplayed the need for mask-wearing and social distancing and even encouraged defiance of such measures. When combined with his constant rhetoric of election fraud, those who believed in Trump may have increased their defiance of such measures to show their continued loyalty to the now former president.”
Professor Croucher says previous research has demonstrated a person’s political affiliation influences their decision to adopt health preventive behaviours as individuals desire approval from others in their political ingroup.
“The results of the current study add to this research by demonstrating that during a period of heightened attention to political ideologies, a national election for example, one’s adherence to a particular ideology heightens an individual’s behaviour response. For Democrats, over time the response was an increased likelihood to wear a mask and wash hands. In contrast, for Republicans it was a decreased likelihood to wear a mask and wash hands to combat COVID-19.”
