Post

Bodybuilding myths, extreme dieting and informed consent

Bodybuilding myths, extreme dieting and informed consent

Source: Auckland University of Technology

18 Nov, 2026

Dr Eric Helms (centre) competes in the 2025 WNBF California Natural Muscle Mayhem. Credit: Better Aesthetics
  • Competing in natural bodybuilding can be done safely but, as with any extreme sport, there are risks.
  • Preparation for the stage includes calorie restriction, for which a slower approach is better than crash dieting.
  • Dr Eric Helms uses his Instagram account to dispel myths such as the promotion of excessively high “protein maxxing”, extreme fad diets, or that demonise particular food groups.

Competing in natural bodybuilding can be rewarding and sustainable, however those interested in doing so should go into it with their eyes open.

This is what Dr Eric Helms told host Susan Strongman, on the AUT podcast Hey, Did You Know?

“There are risks that adults should be well aware of, and they should decide whether it is worth it for them,” Dr Helms said.

“If someone wants to engage in physique sport, which I normally don’t recommend – you can lift weights and look good and not necessarily need to get on stage – then you should go into it with informed consent.”

Dr Helms flies his bodybuilder flag proudly. He researches competitive physique and strength sport, is a natural bodybuilder himself and coach’s other competitors.

The sport is an artistic endeavour that can be done safely, with those who stay in the sport long-term finding a way to make it sustainable, he said.

DR ERIC HELMS ON HEY, DID YOU KNOW? PODCAST. RATE, REVIEW AND SUBSCRIBE!

However, it does push people to extremes, like all competitive sports do, and this introduces risks.

The main extreme for bodybuilders is that for months they deprive themselves of calories to get to minimal levels of body fat for the stage.

Dr Helms said those who attempt to do this by “crash dieting” can have “pretty severe issues” psychologically and physically within weeks – and ultimately fail in their goal to get lean.

A more sustainable approach is slower, where competitors monitor their weight loss over say half a year, he said.

Even so, it might be that a couple of months out from competition negative effects of calorie restriction on the mind and body start to show as competitors strive to get to very low body fat. An evidence-based response to this is to bring the calories up in order to close the energy gap, dieting slower as the body becomes less resilient.

Timing is very important in order to manage the stress of contest preparation so as to compete in peak form.

Dr Helms said physique athletes, like any athletes, need guidance and protection, and good coaches know the limits of their scope of practice and should leverage the support of a dietician and sports psychologist when appropriate.

A minority of those competing at a high level have naturally lean physiques and only need to diet for a couple of months compared to the typical competitor, he said.

DR ERIC HELMS.

Dr Helms is co-director of the AUT Sport Research Institute New Zealand and his research focuses on training and nutrition and physique and strength sport.

His expertise is enriched by personal experience, having coached for over 15 years, and competed 20 times in 18 years, including placing sixth in the Light Heavyweight Men’s Professional Bodybuilding Class at the 2025 World Natural Bodybuilding Federation’s World Championships.

Natural bodybuilding is drug-tested with the intention to provide a level playing field without performance enhancing drugs like anabolic steroids.

Bodybuilding myths

Dr Helms’ Instagram account is where he posts educational content about the science of muscle building, about myths and natural bodybuilding.

Some myths include the promotion of excessively high “protein maxxing” diets, as there is a limit to how much protein is beneficial.

There are also many people that push extreme fad diets or demonise particular food groups. Examples include  completely avoiding carbohydrates out of fear of ill health or weight gain, the carnivore diet, or diets based on false beliefs about what our ancestors ate. These fads swing and change over time, he said.

Black versus white views related to food, especially when layered with body image concerns, can lead to disordered eating, Dr Helms says.

“It takes a little more education, effort, perspective, intentionality to actually institute a more balanced diet, which is hard, right? But they’re the only ones that stick. Many people successfully lose weight. Very few are able to keep it off.”

Useful links

AUT supports the role our academics play as critic and conscience of society, as set out by the Education and Training Act 2020.

Our approach to academic freedom and freedom of expression is set out in our Charter of Academic Freedom which was developed and endorsed by the AUT academic community.

Original source: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/11/18/bodybuilding-myths-extreme-dieting-and-informed-consent/