CoreLogic’s hedonic Home Value Index (HVI) showed another subdued month for the property market in September, with values down by a further 0.5%. That was the seventh monthly fall in a row.
Since February, the declines have now reached a total of 4.7% at the national level, reducing values by $39,399, from $844,825 to $805,426.
Values are still around 16% higher than the March 2020 pre-COVID level, but remain almost 18% below the peak at the height of the post-COVID boom.
The main centres showed a mixed bag of results in September, with Hamilton down 1.2%, Auckland falling a further 0.7% (pushing the recent falls to a total of more than 7%), and Wellington by 0.5%. Yet Tauranga saw a more modest drop of 0.3%, Christchurch was flat, and Dunedin edged up by 0.1%.
CoreLogic NZ Chief Property Economist, Kelvin Davidson said the latest home value data remains patchy and generally sluggish across the country.
“There are signs that lower mortgage rates have started to boost sentiment in the housing market, but this is yet to meaningfully flow through to hard pricing indicators.”
“To be fair, the trough for this latest episode of falling property values may not be far away. But I’d be cautious of assuming that the end of a downturn suddenly means the start of the next upturn. Reasons for caution include still-stretched housing affordability in most parts of the country, an elevated stock of listings on the market, and the weaker employment figures that are now showing through.”
“The Reserve Bank is due to announce the next cash rate decision in early October, followed by the third quarter inflation figures shortly after in the same month. Another OCR cut looks more than likely next week, and hence the near-term path for mortgage rates remains downwards.”
“This should continue into 2025, but lower rates will also bring forward the timing for when the new debt to income restrictions start to bind. DTI rules went live on July 1st, but will become more relevant as borrowing capacity expands alongside lower interest rates, suggesting that any house price upturn next year could be more muted than in the past.”
Index results for September 2024 – National and Main Centres
Auckland
Putting aside these variations from area to area, however, Mr Davidson noted that the bigger picture for Auckland’s housing market is one of generally renewed weakness.
“Each of Auckland’s sub-markets now has a property value that’s at least 1.8% below a year ago, and it’s also pretty striking to note that Auckland City has only seen a rise in values of 4.4% since March 2020. In other words, there’s not much left of the post-COVID boom in that market, perhaps reflecting affordability restraints in its more expensive suburbs, but potentially also patchy demand for apartments.”
Wellington
Mr Davidson noted, “some anecdotes suggest that buyers are starting to eye up the Wellington market again, given a sense that affordability is becoming a bit more normal again, and also that there could be some bargains on offer for investors. However, looser labour market conditions probably loom larger in peoples’ decisions in Wellington than other parts of the country, suggesting that property values aren’t set to surge higher in the near term.”
Regional results
Unsurprisingly, there were some varied results across NZ’s provincial markets in September, with Gisborne, Napier, and Hastings all dropping by more than 1%, but Queenstown was flat, while Nelson and Invercargill inched higher.
Mr Davidson noted that while all areas across NZ face similar pressures from key drivers such as elevated listings and still relatively high (albeit falling) mortgage rates, local factors can still play a very important role.
“Invercargill, for example, may not always be on everybody’s radar as a ‘fashionable’ property market, but values there have risen by 5.2% in the past 12 months, versus a national drop of 1.2%. The revitalisation of the CBD might have been part of that story, but affordability stands out too – a median value of around $460,000 is certainly helping first home buyers to access Invercargill’s property market.”
