Source: MIL-OSI Submissions
Source: Consumer NZ
A recent Consumer NZ investigation of 20 extra-virgin olive oils revealed that some oils labelled as New Zealand also contain imported oils.
“Most oils state the origin of the olives or oil, but not all are upfront, and you could be forgiven for thinking some New Zealand olive oils are made from 100 percent New Zealand olives,”, said Consumer NZ research writer Belinda Castles.
Despite Matapiro New Zealand 100% Extra-Virgin Olive Oil and Village Press First Press Extra-Virgin Olive Oil stating New Zealand on the front label, there’s no mention where the olives or oil comes from.
Matapiro said its oil was blended with Australian olive oil to meet demand. The company is hoping to return to wholly New Zealand grown olives and oil soon.
Village Press said its First Press blend is typically New Zealand extra-virgin oil blended with Australian oil. The company told Consumer NZ the reference to New Zealand represents that it is a local business where all oil is blended, filtered, bottled and labelled within the country. Village Press told Consumer NZ the label will be amended at its next harvest so it’s clear not all the First Press oil is New Zealand sourced.
New country of origin regulations, which come into force for fresh food from 12 February 2022, make it mandatory for companies to disclose the origin of certain foods such as fruit and vegetables, meat and cured pork, and fish and shellfish. Olive oil is not covered by the regulations.
Consumer NZ is asking for regulations to include all single ingredient foods and olive oil falls into this category.
Consumer NZ olive oil results
Consumer NZ tested 20 extra-virgin olive oils from New Zealand, Australia, Africa, and Europe. All oils met the criteria to be labelled extra-virgin and two Kiwi oils achieved gold medal standard (86 to 100 percent) in the blind tasting carried out by accredited tasters.
Olivo Extra-Virgin Olive Oil ($5.99 per 100ml) tasted of “complex green herbs with hints of lime and a peppery finish”. Kapiti Extra-Virgin Olive Oil Leccino/Picual ($4.70 per 100ml) was described as a very well-balanced oil, tasting of “oregano, artichoke, rocket and apple” with a “white pepper finish”.
These two oils also carry the OliveMark – Olives New Zealand (the New Zealand olive oil industry body) certification.
To qualify for OliveMark, an oil must meet requirements for bottling and labelling as well as chemical and sensory criteria.
Nine oils achieved silver medal status (76 to 85 percent), including four oils that are good value ($2.04 or less per 100ml).
Bronze (65 to 75 percent) was awarded to six oils from Australia, New Zealand and Europe.
Three oils didn’t achieve a medal in the Consumer NZ tasting. They were Harvest Extra-Virgin Olive Oil, Olivani Extra-Virgin Olive Oil and Countdown Extra-Virgin Olive Oil.
Fresh is best when it comes to olive oils, but none of these oils had a pressed-on or harvest date so you don’t know how old the oil is.
What to look for when buying olive oil
Buy the freshest oil possible. Look for a pressed-on or harvest date. Best-before dates aren’t always a good indicator of quality, as you don’t know how old the oil can be.
Green or dark bottles, or tins, provide better protection from the light. Don’t buy clear-bottled oils, especially ones that have been displayed in a shop window or under fluorescent light.
Store in a cool dark place, tightly stoppered.
Don’t stockpile. Oils don’t improve with age so use any open oil within 12 months.
Our test
Consumer NZ’s test and tasting were conducted by the International Olive Council accredited NSW Department of Primary Industries Oil Testing Service at the Wagga Wagga Agricultural Institute. The test included three chemical tests and a sensory analysis of the oils. Product samples were purchased by Consumer NZ.
About Consumer
Consumer NZ is a non-profit organisation, with 60 years of helping New Zealanders get a fairer deal. In addition to our product tests, we investigate consumer issues and campaign to improve consumer rights. We don’t take advertising. Our work is mainly funded by our members and supporters.
