Climate change throws tree seeding out of sync – new study

Source: University of Canterbury – statements

Many tree species worldwide produce large seed crops at irregular intervals, known as mast seeding. New Zealanders are probably already aware of this because in three of the last six years (2014, 2016 and 2019) the Department of Conservation has had to run extensive pest control operations over very large areas, says University of Canterbury Professor Dave Kelly, School of Biological Sciences, a co-author on the study. The pest control was required to protect rare native birds from booming populations of two key predators, rodents and stoats, which increased after big seed crops in southern beech (Nothofagus) forests.

Consequences for animals, insects

A key unanswered question is how climate change will affect the frequency of big seed years, and what the consequences will be for animals that feed on these seeds. The new international study published today (11 Feb NZ time) in the journal Nature Plants has used 39 years of data on European beech (Fagus) trees throughout Britain.

“At the start of the study, the beech trees gained major benefits from irregular big seed crops,” says Professor Kelly. “Pollination worked better, and losses to seed predators – a native moth – were kept low because the moth had little to eat in the famine years between big seed crops. Benefits like this are the evolutionary reasons that trees show mast seeding in the first place.”

But over the decades of the study, seed production by the beech trees steadily increased due to the warming climate. That should have been good news for the plant, but instead turned out to only be good for the seed-eating moth.

Lead author Dr Michał Bogdziewicz from Adam Mickiewicz University, Poland, explains further: “The disappearance of the characteristic ‘boom and bust’ seed production patterns in UK beech trees, as the climate warmed up, has led to an increase in moth populations. As a result, we have seen a dramatic increase in the percentage of the seeds that are eaten by the moth larvae – up from around 1 percent in the 1980s to 40 percent in recent years”.

The net effect was that complex interactions between species nullified any benefit to forests.

Co-author Dr Andrew Hacket-Pain, University of Liverpool, says: “Any benefit the trees might gain from this increased reproductive effort has been almost entirely offset by higher seed consumption by the moth larvae. The trees are producing more seeds, but gaining almost no return on their increased investment. It is an excellent example of how the overall response of forests to climate change is dependent on a complex web of interactions between species”.

Important lessons for New Zealand

Professor Kelly says there are important lessons for New Zealand, and many other countries which have mast seeding trees.

“We need to understand not only how the plants and the animals respond to warmer climates, but also how they interact. For example, ship rats in New Zealand have been spreading to higher altitudes in recent decades, which will alter local responses to southern beech mast seed crops. Overall, seeding strategies which worked well for forest trees in the past may increasingly fail under new climate conditions,” he says.

The new research, which also involved researchers at Keele University and Manchester Metropolitan University, will be published in the journal Nature Plants. The paper titled, ‘Climate warming disrupts mast seeding and its fitness benefits in European beech’ can be read from 11 February (NZ time): https://www.nature.com/articles/s41477-020-0592-8 (DOI: 10.1038/s41477-020-0592-8).

For more information or to request interviews, please contact:

Professor Dave Kelly, Biological Sciences, College of Science, dave.kelly@canterbury.ac.nz, Phone: +6433695182 or 027 2551537

or UC Communications team, media@canterbury.ac.nz, Ph: (03) 369 3631 or 027 5030168.

MIL OSI